Why Most "Grit" Advice Is Complete Rubbish: A Realist's Guide to Actually Building Resilience

Other Blogs of Interest:

• Learning Sphere Blog
• Development Hub Posts

Here's something that'll probably annoy the self-help crowd: most people talking about "grit" have never actually failed at anything meaningful. They've read Angela Duckworth's book, watched a TED talk, and now they're experts on perseverance. Absolute codswallop.

I've been in business consulting for seventeen years across Melbourne, Sydney, and Brisbane, and I can tell you that real grit isn't what Instagram motivational quotes make it out to be. It's messier, uglier, and frankly more boring than anyone wants to admit.

The Problem With Pretty Grit

The sanitised version of grit you see everywhere makes it sound like some noble character trait that successful people are just born with. Nonsense.

Real grit is showing up to work when your biggest client just told you they're going with your competitor because their nephew "knows about marketing." It's rebuilding your entire business model when technology makes your service obsolete. Again.

Most importantly, it's knowing when NOT to be gritty. And this is where 73% of business owners get it completely wrong.

I learned this the hard way in 2019. Had a consulting contract with a manufacturing firm in Adelaide that was hemorrhaging money. Classic case of throwing good money after bad. I spent eight months trying to "show grit" and fix their operational mess, when what they really needed was to pivot their entire business model.

What Actually Builds Grit (Hint: It's Not Willpower)

Forget everything you've heard about willpower and mental toughness. That's American nonsense that doesn't work long-term.

Strategy One: Build Systems, Not Habits

Everyone bangs on about creating good habits. But habits break under pressure. Systems don't.

When KPMG restructured their Melbourne office in 2020, the partners who survived weren't the ones with the best morning routines. They were the ones who had built robust client retention systems that worked regardless of their mood or energy levels.

Your grit isn't tested when everything's going well. It's tested when your systems need to carry you through the tough periods.

Strategy Two: Embrace Strategic Quitting

Here's an unpopular opinion that'll make productivity gurus lose their minds: sometimes quitting is the grittiest thing you can do.

I've watched too many business owners destroy their health, relationships, and bank accounts because they confused stubbornness with persistence. There's a massive difference between strategic persistence and bloody-minded stupidity.

Smart quitting means cutting your losses before they cut you. It means recognising when you're pursuing something because of ego rather than logic.

Strategy Three: Develop Antifragility

This concept comes from Nassim Taleb, and it's brilliant. Most people aim for resilience - bouncing back to where they were. But antifragile systems actually get stronger from stress.

Look at companies like Atlassian. Every challenge in their growth phase made them more robust, not just more resilient. They didn't just survive disruption; they used it as fuel.

The Australian Advantage (Yes, Really)

Despite what the cultural cringe brigade tells you, we actually have some natural advantages when it comes to building real grit.

Our tall poppy syndrome, while sometimes limiting, teaches us to handle criticism and setbacks without taking them personally. We're pragmatic by nature. We don't waste time on flowery motivational speeches when there's actual work to be done.

Plus, our business environment is tough enough that if you can succeed here, you can probably succeed anywhere. Try running a hospitality business in Sydney with the rent prices and regulations we have. That'll teach you grit faster than any course ever could.

The Compound Effect Nobody Talks About

Real grit compounds differently than people expect. It's not linear progress; it's exponential patience.

Most people expect their persistence to pay off within months. But the biggest breakthroughs often come after years of seemingly unrewarded effort. I've seen this pattern repeatedly with successful entrepreneurs in Perth's mining services sector. They weathered multiple boom-bust cycles before finding their groove.

The trick is building what I call "sustainable intensity" - working at a level you can maintain for years, not months.

What They Don't Tell You About Setbacks

Every business book talks about "learning from failure" like it's some enlightening experience. Sometimes failure is just bloody awful and there's nothing to learn except "don't do that again."

The real skill isn't extracting wisdom from every setback. It's developing the emotional resilience to move forward without needing every experience to be a learning opportunity.

Some days you just need to accept that things went badly, dust yourself off, and try again tomorrow. No profound insights required.

Strategy Four: Build Your Support Infrastructure

This isn't about having a mentor or joining a networking group (though those can help). It's about creating practical support systems that function when you're too exhausted to function properly.

Successful people in demanding fields - whether it's managing workplace anxiety or running complex operations - understand that grit isn't a solo sport. They build teams, processes, and backup plans that help them persist when individual willpower fails.

The Money Talk Nobody Wants to Have

Here's the uncomfortable truth: financial pressure either builds character or destroys it, but it rarely leaves people unchanged.

I've consulted with family businesses where the second generation had never experienced real financial stress. When challenging times hit, they lacked the grit their parents had developed through necessity.

Conversely, I've seen entrepreneurs who grew up with genuine financial hardship develop almost superhuman persistence. Not because poverty is noble, but because they've learned that comfort is temporary and you need to work for what you want.

The key is finding ways to simulate that pressure without actually risking everything. Set aggressive but achievable targets. Create artificial deadlines. Make your success measurable and make the measurements matter.

Why Most Corporate Grit Training Fails

Large organisations spend millions on resilience training that doesn't work because they're trying to teach grit in environments that reward mediocrity.

You can't develop real persistence in a system where showing up is sufficient and excellence is optional. It's like trying to build muscle by thinking about exercise.

Companies like Virgin Australia understand this. Their customer service training doesn't just teach scripts; it puts people in genuinely challenging situations where they need to find solutions. That's where real grit develops.

Real grit comes from necessity, not inspiration. If you want to build it in yourself or your team, create environments where persistence is required, not just encouraged.

The Long Game

Building genuine grit is a decade-long project, not a weekend workshop outcome.

The people who succeed long-term are usually the ones who started working on their persistence skills years before they needed them. They're like those Perth mining executives who maintained their fitness during the good times so they could handle the physical demands when projects got tough.

Start now. Build slowly. And remember that the goal isn't to become invincible - it's to become reliably persistent when it matters most.

Because at the end of the day, grit isn't about never falling down. It's about getting good at getting back up. And in Australian business, that skill is worth its weight in iron ore.